ACR-News
Know what you want? Try our 'Supplier Directory' 

Rabbits, tigers and air-conditioning inspections

Happy Chinese Lunar New Year! The Year of the Rabbit started on February 3rd and I spent the evening at the Institute of Refrigeration's evening paper held in Birmingham on Hydrocarbons in commercial refrigeration. Although perhaps not the traditional way to celebrate, it was an extremely interesting evening which judging by the turnout, was a very popular event with others too.

According to tradition, the Rabbit is the fourth sign in the Chinese Horoscope and signifies calm, diplomacy, sensitivity and consideration for others. It is said that during this year, good taste and refinement will shine on everything and people will acknowledge that persuasion is better than force. A congenial time in which diplomacy will be given a front seat again and we will act with discretion and make reasonable concessions without too much difficulty.
I was mindful of this while listening to the presentation, and although the paper obviously described previous installations (as well as plans for the future), the pragmatic and yet novel approach taken by Waitrose, was a perfect balance of tried and tested technology being stretched and used in a leading edge application. So clever, and yet so simple. An integrated approach to the cooling and the HVAC requirement in the modern retail sector. Congratulations to all involved in the project and in presenting such an interesting paper.
Another characteristic of a rabbit year is that law and order will be lax; that rules and regulations will not be rigidly enforced, unlike the previous year which was that of the tiger which is thought of as a year of battles. Oh dear, surely this can't be correct and not a good omen for anyone expecting the F-Gas regulations to be enforced? The outgoing tiger year was the final month in which all air-conditioning systems with a rated output greater than 12kW but less than 250kW must have had the first inspection. The actual date for completing these inspections was 4th January 2011.
It has been estimated that something like only 3% of air-conditioning systems have actually been inspected. The figure may be slightly higher, but it doubtful that is it over 5% at best. These inspections are not meant to be some optional requirement that the operators of the systems can chose to ignore if they please. They are a legal requirement under European law and it seems that 95% or more of air-conditioning systems in this output range are now operating illegally.
The merits of air-conditioning inspections have been debated and the process is not without its critics. However, whether one agrees with the detail of these inspections or not, one must accept that the enforcement of them has been, and still is a farce. The lax approach taken by government to this makes a mockery, not only of the legislation itself, but of the many people from the ACR industry who have gained certification to enable them to carry-out the inspections only to find that operators have little incentive to comply. It is indicative of the lip-service that government pay to this industry and the environment. Perhaps if we were to turn all the non-compliant air-conditioning systems off, people might sit-up and take notice.
There is some wonderful work and innovation taking place in our industry. The Waitrose paper provided yet another fine example of this. To use the rabbit metaphor: the ACR industry is coming along in leaps and bounds. Unfortunately, the lack of enforcement for the air-conditioning inspections, F-Gas regulations, pressure systems regulations, and many other regulations, continues to divide the industry and allow non-compliant practises to continue unchecked. If 2010 really was the year of the tiger, it was one without teeth and claws.
Some would have us believe that the government's hands-off approach is because they trust us as a mature industry to self-regulate. The more cynical would claim that it is case of apathy rules, but no one cares.
View User Profile for SteveGill Steve Gill has worked in the ACR industry for over 30 years as a contractor and consultant. He is a member of the Institute of Refrigeration Executive Council and a former Director of ACRIB. He was the winner of the ACR News `Consultant of the Year Award` in 2011, 2013 and 2014.
Posted by Steve Gill 04 February 2011 10:10:20 Categories: Fresh Talk

Comments

By Rob Lee
04 February 2011 10:15:20
I agree with all the previous entires; Steve, Kevin and Paul all make vaid points.
As Kevin says, it is eat or be eaten, but so many out there are doing nothing except bemoan their lot. As least this debate is public here. Well done ACR News for being an industry forum and airing our concerns.
By Mark Jones
04 February 2011 10:14:20
I agree with Steve. Having qualified to be an a/c inspector I find that there is no support from Government for actually having these inspections carried out. Limp trade press comunications from from the so called 'trade bodies' are as useless as the government's own policing of the inspections.
Well done Steve for saying what many of us are thinking.
By Kevin Savage
04 February 2011 10:13:20
Steve Gill has a valid point about F-Gas, Pressure System Regulations and AC Inspections. The latter of these should, when proliferated throuhout the market, discover and report on non-compliance of the former two.

There is and will remain for considerable time a shortfall in compliance of AC Inspections, some due in part from the very small number of inspectors also due to poor market awareness, small fines and low levels of enforcement.

The merits of AC Inspection, lower fuel bills, greener credentials for those who see the process as helpful have not been effectively passed to the owners and users of air conditioning technologies from the very industry supposed to be serving this sector.

In this respect we must consider contractors, designers and manufacturers to be side stepping an obvious opportunity for billions of s' of potential trade and an almost unheard of commercial advantage over their rivals!

Who's missing the point, make your blue chip and national chains aware of the potential to improve on energy consumption, equipment reliability, sharpen the organisations awareness of related legislation and assist in CO2 reduction.

Well at least for those who are advising the client base ahead of their competition get stand an excellent chance of expanding their market share at the expense of the competition!

It's like an eat or be eaten situation.
By Kevin Savage
04 February 2011 10:12:20
To all as a response to comments by Paul Skeet.

Similar events surrounded R12 phase out, there seems a modicum of desperation and frustration within the client/user pressure group and engineering companies not wishing to offence whilst capitalising on an opportunity.

One should expet rogue practices as part of human nature, anyway there seems to be non-compliance and other cavalier practices going on whilst the government appointed enforcing wing take fright over potential implosion due to fiscal changes.

I have yet to see how reducing 1/3 of funds to local government can improve compliance unless the government intend another centrally controlled Quango (sorry I hear these were recently due to be disbanded) to police their intent.

Well meant but meaningless, we have our industry to blame by not taking the initiative to replace older less efficient R22 plant that must in most situations be becoming less reliable and frankly near clapped out!

Therefore I reiterate "why buy R22?"
By Paul Skeet, ACCORD AIR SYSTEMS
04 February 2011 10:11:20
I think its the latter I'm afraid - no one cares. Especially as we're all trying to survive the recession and just concentrate on getting new work in. its a case of not 'rocking the boat' for a year or 2 til we recover. it does though make a mockery of the principle & good intent. ps. Would someone please tell me why you can still buy R22 - as recycled gas? (albeit v. expensive)
Comments are closed on this post.
ACR News is the number one magazine in the air conditioning and refrigeration industry. Don’t miss out, subscribe today!
Subcribe to ACR News

Diary

BESA National Conference